After a loved one dies, one of the first matters that people turn their minds to is planning the funeral. In some instances, a dispute can arise between close relatives or friends about the funeral, such disputes can include:
- Family members feeling excluded from the funeral planning.
- Whether the body should be cremated or buried
- The location of the funeral or burial
- What happens to the ashes after cremation?
During such an emotional and distressing time, disputes can escalate, and parties can find it difficult to find a solution, especially as it is often misunderstood whose responsibility it is to arrange the funeral.
Who has a duty to dispose of the body?
It is accepted that there is ‘no property in a corpse’, therefore a body cannot be sold, gifted, or disposed of by a Will. If funeral wishes are included in a Will, these are not legal binding, and they cannot be enforced.
However, the law provides an order of priority for individuals who have a right to ‘possess a body’ and have the authority to arrange the funeral. If there is a Will, then the executor is entitled to possession. If there is no Will, then it is the person who has priority on intestacy (in order, this will be a surviving spouse, children, parents, then siblings of the deceased).
Therefore, it is usually the executor who has a duty to dispose of the body and arrange the funeral. Where funeral wishes have been expressed, although not binding, it is usual for these wishes to be followed to avoid a potential dispute.
However, when a dispute does arise the Court can be called upon to make a decision regarding the disposal of the body.
What power does the Court have to intervene with funeral disputes?
The Court can assist under one of three different powers, which are:
- Under their inherent jurisdiction to direct who should have control over the burial of a body; or
- Under section 116 of the Senior Courts Act 1981, the Court can appoint someone to be a personal representative to an estate, who would then have the authority to dispose of the body; or
- under CPR 64.2 (a) (i) the Court has the power to determine any question arising in the administration of the estate of a deceased person.
What factors will the Court consider when making a decision regarding the funeral/burial?
The Court will primarily want to ensure that the deceased’s body is treated with respect and dignity. In Hartshorn v Gardner [2008] EWHC 3675 (Ch) the Court confirmed that they would consider the following factors when reaching a decision:
- The deceased’s wishes;
- The reasonable wishes of family and friends;
- The place the deceased was most closely connected with; and
- Practicalities for the proposed burial
What if a dispute arises about the ashes after cremation?
Assistance of the Court can also be sought in relation to a dispute regarding ashes. The Court will consider the same factors from Hartshorn as listed above when making a decision. In Fessi v Whitmore [1999] 1 FLR 767 the judge found that it would be “wholly inappropriate” for the ashes to be divided between the parents of the deceased.
What should I do if a dispute arises?
We would advise that you seek legal advice as soon as possible. If a funeral has been planned, then an injunction can be sought to prevent the burial until a final decision has been made by the Court or agreed between the parties.
Contact our Contentious probate Team
If you are concerned about the funeral arrangements of a loved one, please contact Tiggy Hawkesworth on 020 7631 4141 or email contentiousprobate@bishopandsewell.co.uk
The above is accurate as at 21 June 2022. The information above may be subject to change during these ever-changing times.
The content of this note should not be considered legal advice and each matter should be considered on a case-by-case basis.
